The best regional burger styles in America are the El Reno fried onion burger, the Minneapolis Jucy Lucy, the Wisconsin butter burger, the Mississippi slugburger, the Southern pimento cheeseburger, the New Mexico green chile cheeseburger and the classic smash burger. My winner is the Jucy Lucy. My skip is the smash burger, since you can already get one almost anywhere.
Published November 19, 2026.
I’ve done enough long drives through other states to know a good regional burger is worth a detour, and I’ll pick the diner with a faded sign over the chain by the highway every time. Each style here grew out of a real reason: cheap filler during hard times, a dairy state showing off, a chile harvest nobody wanted to waste. Knowing that story makes the first bite better.
A practical note before you plan a trip around any of these: small-town diners often keep short hours. Some close by mid-afternoon or skip a weekday, so check before you drive an hour for lunch. Pulling up to a dark window is a sad way to end a detour.
Regional burger styles at a glance
| Style | Home base | What makes it different |
|---|---|---|
| Fried onion burger | El Reno, Oklahoma | Onions smashed and griddled right into the patty |
| Jucy Lucy | Minneapolis, Minnesota | Cheese stuffed inside the patty, not on top |
| Butter burger | Wisconsin | Butter on the bun or melted onto the patty |
| Slugburger | Corinth, Mississippi | Patty stretched with filler, then deep-fried |
| Pimento cheeseburger | The South | Topped with pimento cheese instead of a cheese slice |
| Green chile cheeseburger | New Mexico | Roasted green chiles piled on top |
| Smash burger | Nationwide | Thin patty pressed hard on a hot griddle for a crispy edge |
1. The El Reno Fried Onion Burger: Where It All Started
This one came out of hard times and stayed because it’s better. During the Depression, cooks in El Reno, Oklahoma, piled thin-sliced onions on the griddle and pressed the patty down into them. The onions cooked into the meat instead of beside it, and they stretched a small bit of beef into a full meal.
What you get is sweet, browned onion in every bite, with crispy bits stuck to the edge of the patty. Three old diners still make them on adjoining blocks downtown. Robert’s Grill, the oldest, opened in 1926. Johnnie’s Grill and Sid’s Diner sit close by, so you can try two in one stop if you’re hungry enough. The town also throws a burger festival every May.
Best for: anyone who thinks burgers need more onion, not less, and wants to taste where the idea began.
Skip it if: you don’t love onions. They aren’t a garnish here; they’re most of the bite.
2. The Jucy Lucy: My Winner, and the Cheese Is the Point
Two Minneapolis bars have argued for decades over who invented this one, and neither needs to win for it to be the best on this list. Matt’s Bar and the 5-8 Club have both claimed it since the 1950s, as Explore Minnesota tells it. Matt’s spells it “Jucy,” and the 5-8 Club spells it “Juicy.” The cheese goes inside the raw patty before cooking, so it melts into a hidden, molten center.
That surprise is why it wins. You bite through a plain-looking burger and hot cheese runs out. It’s simple enough to make at home, too: two thin patties, a slice of cheese folded between them, edges pinched shut.
Best for: the first bite, which is the whole appeal. Let it rest for a minute or you’ll regret it.
Skip it if: you want to control your own cheese amount. This one decides for you, and it’s a lot.
3. The Wisconsin Butter Burger: Dairy State, No Apologies
Wisconsin doesn’t hide that it’s a dairy state, and this burger is the proof. Milwaukee spots like Solly’s Grille have been serving butter burgers since the 1930s, with a big spoonful of butter melting right on top of the patty. Culver’s, the chain that opened in 1984, made the ButterBurger famous far beyond the state, though it butters the toasted bun instead.
Either way, the butter turns an ordinary burger rich and a little decadent. The old-school Milwaukee version is the one to seek out if you’re in the state. The butter pools on the plate, and you’ll want the bun to soak it up.
Best for: cold-weather eating, or anyone who thinks a burger should feel like a treat.
Skip it if: you’d rather keep things light that day. There’s no light version of melted butter.

4. The Slugburger: Mississippi’s Depression-Era Stretch
The name scares people off, and the story behind it is the best part. In Corinth, Mississippi, a cook named John Weeks started selling a stretched-out burger in 1917. His recipe mixed the beef with potato flakes and flour, and soy grits took over later. Cooks keep the patty small and deep-fry it instead of grilling it.
The town’s favorite story is that the name came from the price. The burger once sold for a nickel, and “slug” was slang for a nickel-sized coin. Corinth has held a Slugburger Festival downtown every July since 1988.
Best for: the crunch. The deep-fried edge is nothing like a griddled patty, and that’s the reason to try one.
Skip it if: you want a burger that tastes mostly like beef. The filler changes the texture on purpose.
5. The Pimento Cheeseburger: The South’s Favorite Spread, on a Patty
Pimento cheese shows up on crackers, in sandwiches and at tailgates across the South, so putting it on a burger was never a stretch. The spread is usually sharp cheddar, mayonnaise and chopped pimentos. It melts just enough to coat the patty without disappearing into it.
It’s less one diner’s invention than a whole region landing on the same good idea. That also makes it the easiest one on this list to make at home. Stir up a bowl of pimento cheese, spoon it onto the hot patty and let it slump for a few seconds before the bun goes on.
Best for: anyone who already loves pimento cheese and hasn’t thought to put it on a burger.
Skip it if: you’re not a mayonnaise person. The spread’s texture depends on it.
6. The Green Chile Cheeseburger: New Mexico’s Official Pick
New Mexico takes this one seriously enough to build a state trail around it. The state tourism department maps a Green Chile Cheeseburger Trail of restaurants that pile roasted green chiles on a cheeseburger. Readers of USA Today’s 10Best once voted it the top food trail in the country.
The chile has to be roasted, not raw. Roasting gives it a smoky heat that a plain jalapeño doesn’t come close to. Late summer is roasting season, when the smell of chiles turning in big drums drifts through parking lots across the state.
Best for: anyone who wants real heat with real flavor behind it, not just spice for its own sake.
Skip it if: you’re sensitive to heat. Green chiles vary by harvest, and some years run hotter than others.
7. The Smash Burger: My Skip, Because It’s Already Everywhere
This is the one I’d rank last. It’s not bad at all; it has just stopped being regional. A thin patty gets pressed hard onto a screaming-hot griddle so the edges turn lacy and crisp. Nobody agrees on where it started. Thin, pressed patties go back to some of the earliest American hamburger stands, and a few old diners in Kentucky and Indiana have their own claims.
Fast-casual chains brought it back in a big way in the 2000s and 2010s. Now most cities have a dozen places doing it well. It’s a great burger, but you won’t find one on the road that you can’t find closer to home.
Best for: a reliably good burger wherever you are, with no planning required.
Skip it if: you’re chasing the regional six above. This is the one you can already get at home.
A Road-Trip Order for Trying All Seven
If you’re building a trip or just a backyard cookout menu around these, go from mild to intense instead of at random:
- Start with the butter burger or the pimento cheeseburger. Both are rich but not spicy, and they’re the easiest sell to a picky eater.
- Move to the fried onion burger and the slugburger. Both have a strong, specific texture, so you want your palate fresh for them.
- Save the Jucy Lucy for when you can sit down and wait for it to cool. It’s messy, and rushing it burns your mouth.
- Finish with the green chile cheeseburger. The heat lingers, so it’s the wrong one to eat before anything milder.
If you’re hosting rather than traveling, cook the onions, mix the pimento cheese and roast the chiles a day ahead. It’s the same logic behind any realistic weekly meal-prep system: do the slow parts early and the fast parts fresh. Pair the spread with something cold. Our apple cider mocktail recipes work well next to a smoky green chile burger if you want something non-alcoholic on the table.
The grill is the bottleneck at a cookout, as anyone who has hosted one knows. Smash burgers and onion burgers cook in a few minutes each, so make those to order. A Jucy Lucy needs longer and a rest, so start those first.
What Actually Makes a Burger “Regional”?
A style earns the label when a place did something to the basic patty that nowhere else was doing, usually for a practical reason. El Reno had plenty of onions and not much meat. Corinth needed a burger it could sell for a nickel. New Mexico had a chile crop too good to waste.
The smash burger shows what happens when a style is too good and too simple to stay put: it spreads until it belongs to everyone. The other six still taste best close to home, which is why they’re worth the drive. If you’d rather bring them to your own table, the planning tips in our guide to hosting a festive Friendsgiving work just as well for a cookout built around any of these.
Frequently asked questions about regional burger styles
What is the most famous regional burger in America?
The Minneapolis Jucy Lucy is probably the best known outside its own region. Its cheese-stuffed center is a simple idea to explain and a real surprise the first time you bite into it. The New Mexico green chile cheeseburger comes close, helped along by the state’s own food trail.
Where did the fried onion burger come from?
El Reno, Oklahoma, during the Great Depression. Cooks stretched a small amount of meat by smashing a pile of thin-sliced onions into the patty on the griddle. Robert’s Grill, open since 1926, still makes them, and the town holds a festival for the burger every May.
Is a smash burger a regional style?
Not anymore. Its origin is still argued over, and it has spread to every part of the country, so it no longer feels tied to one place. That’s why it’s my pick to skip on a list built around flavors you can’t easily get at home.
What makes a Jucy Lucy different from a regular cheeseburger?
The cheese goes inside the raw patty before cooking instead of on top afterward, so it melts into a hidden pocket at the center. Two Minneapolis bars, Matt’s Bar and the 5-8 Club, have each claimed to have invented it since the 1950s, and both still serve their own version.




